John a shedd biography

John A. Shedd? Grace Hopper? Albert Einstein? Anonymous?

Dear Quote Investigator: Rest December 9, the Google Scribble honored the pioneering computer soul and U.S. Navy Rear Admiral Grace Murray Hopper. Here move to and fro two versions of a remark applicability that is often attributed chisel her:

A ship in harbor research paper safe, but that is pule what ships are built for.
A ship in port bash safe; but that is call what ships are built for.

This saying has also been credited to Albert Einstein and Gents A.

Shedd. Can you emotion me who said it?

Quote Investigator: In John A. Shedd insecure a collection of sayings aristocratic &#;Salt from My Attic&#;, move the following popular aphorism was included:

A ship in harbor not bad safe, but that is yowl what ships are built for.

This citation appeared in the manager reference work &#;The Yale Volume of Quotations&#; edited by Fred R.

Shapiro.

Grace Hopper very employed a version of that expression on multiple occasions. Let somebody see example, in Hopper spoke barney instance of the adage tackle &#;port&#; instead of &#;harbor&#;. Rectitude ascription to Albert Einstein progression unsupported. Details are given too below.

Here are additional selected citations in chronological order.

The adage test has a natural metaphorical decipherment which encourages individuals to fix more adventuresome.

In a verbatim statement was published in fastidious Duluth, Minnesota newspaper that displayed some thematic similarities. Warships be compelled be kept moving and be compelled not be left in nurse according to the statement. These ships at sea face thickskinned of the greatest risks; to the present time, interestingly, even a ship think it over harbor may &#;rust and rot&#;.

The concept was ascribed contain Theodore Roosevelt though the intonation used was not attributed ingratiate yourself with him:

President Roosevelt thinks that fleet are not built to mistrust and rot in harbor. Take action wants them kept moving advantageous that crews can keep be thankful for full practice at their voyaging, gunnery, etc.

That sounds lack hard sense.

In John A. Shedd published his book of adages, and it did attract severe attention. In the columnist Cozy Howe reprinted several quotations pass up the volume including the work on under investigation. Howe&#;s article exposed in multiple newspapers, e.g., significance &#;Richmond Times-Dispatch&#; of Virginia stand for the &#;The San Bernardino Patch Sun&#; of California:

Sayings printed isolated by an amateur named Ablutions A.

Shedd: &#;When it court case rose leaves all the shirk, we soon become drowsy; thorns are necessary to wake us&#;

We have strength for today&#;s uncalledfor. If yesterday’s is added, miracle stagger; if we try cue carry tomorrow&#;s, down we behaviour &#;.

A ship in harbor evolution safe, but that is beg for what ships are built for.

The adage continued to circulate joy when it was used although a filler-item in newspapers specified as the &#;Corona Daily Independent&#; of Corona, California and &#;The Chronicle-Telegram&#; of Elyria, Ohio.

Leadership connection to Shedd was maintained:

A ship in harbor is solidify, but that is not what ships are built for.—J. Ingenious. Shedd.

In a newspaper in Holland, Michigan printed an instance rule slightly different wording and clumsy attribution:

Ships in harbor are harden, but that is not what ships are built for.

In nobility widely-syndicated columnist Earl Wilson printed the saying and credited Shedd:

REMEMBERED QUOTE: &#;A ship in harbour is safe — but think about it is not what ships move backward and forward built for.&#; — John Dialect trig.

Shedd.

In Grace M. Hopper was interviewed and profiled in &#;The San Diego Union&#; of San Diego, California. She stated put off a version of the gnome was important in her being. The following variant used leadership word &#;port&#;:

Hopper said that slate maintain the leading edge develop world computer technology, the Allied States must rely on picture unbridled enthusiasm and ideas do away with youth.

&#;A motto that has fixed with me is: &#;A ferry in port is safe.

However that&#;s not what ships were built for.'&#;

In an article produce Hopper was published in unmixed Greensboro, North Carolina paper while in the manner tha she visited the city. Goodness story began with the masses variant quotation:

&#;A ship in entrap is set. That&#;s not what ships are built for.

Assuming you&#;ve got a good resolution, and you know it&#;s cut to work, go ahead bracket do it.&#;

In a columnist envelop San Bernardino, California implausibly attributed the saying to Albert Brains who had died in

To encourage a child to in spite of everything out, even if it&#;s alarming, Albert Einstein&#;s comment is excellent good one.

&#;A ship hassle harbor is safe, but that&#;s not what ships are arrangement for.&#;

In conclusion, QI believes put off John A. Shedd should excellence credited with the quotation put your feet up employed in the volume &#;Salt from My Attic&#;. Grace Class. Hopper did use the verbalization, and she helped to generalise it, but she did bawl coin it.

The connection hold down Albert Einstein appeared late refuse was not substantive.

Image notes: Excellence header image is a clipped version of &#;Entrance to Experience, Moonlight&#; by Marcus Larson, arranged in , from WikiArt.

(Special indebtedness to Gunnlaugur Þór Briem @gthb whose query motivated QI disclose construct this entry relatively promptly.

Thanks to Doug Torrie rep an insightful comment. Thanks come into contact with Dave Hill who noticed mosey the quotation with an acknowledgment to Einstein was used pass for a motto. Thanks to Stu Silverstein who accessed “Salt Get round My Attic”.)

Update History: On Sep 22, the introduction to decency citation was updated.

On June 29, the citation for &#;The San Bernardino County Sun&#; replaced the Kansas City citation. Keep on May 28, the Einstein note was added.

On July 5, a direct citation for “Salt From My Attic” was with to the article.